The Joe Rogan Experience

#2370 - Dave Smith

Podcast Joe Rogan and Dave Smith 9/19/2025

Overall summary: The conversation is a mix of legitimate political analysis and conspiratorial thinking. While the speakers cite some valid sources and acknowledge uncertainty at times, they frequently engage in sweeping generalizations, us-vs-them framing, and apocalyptic rhetoric. The discussion of Israel-Palestine is particularly charged with emotional language and one-sided presentations. Dave Smith makes some valid critiques of US foreign policy but often overstates his case with absolute claims. The conversation shows both genuine attempts at analysis and significant bias, with fact-checking revealing a mix of accurate claims, misleading statements, and some outright falsehoods. The overall tone alternates between constructive criticism and inflammatory rhetoric.

Highlights

Good Faith: Acknowledging Counterarguments, Admitting Uncertainty, Citing Evidence
Fallacies: Ad Hominem, Hasty Generalization, False Dichotomy
Cultish Language: Us vs. Them, Apocalyptic Rhetoric, Absolute Statements
Fact Check Highlights: The Federal Reserve was created in 1913 — True; Nixon took the US off the gold standard in 1971 — True; 70% of Ukrainians want immediate end to war with negotiations — Misleading

🤝

3 Good Faith Indicators

⚠️

3 Logical Fallacies

🧠

3 Cultish / Manipulative Language

🔍

6 Fact Checks

🤝 Good Faith Indicators

3 findings

Acknowledging Counterarguments

Recognizing and addressing opposing viewpoints

Examples:

Dave Smith (4m 14s): 'But also, You know, to a, to ask that question is to answer that question.'
Joe Rogan (3m 17s): 'Or you can only ask me a few things in life that I can give you like definitive answers on. Yeah. And even then I, I might have to refer to expert.'

Why it matters: Both speakers acknowledge limitations in their knowledge and the validity of opposing perspectives

Admitting Uncertainty

Expressing doubt or lack of complete knowledge

Examples:

Dave Smith (1h 19m 0s): 'I think they have that, she had a few, did they'
Joe Rogan (1h 56m 4s): 'I don't know what the fuck happened.'
Dave Smith (4m 32s): 'Yeah, I've heard, I've heard the clip. It was pretty good. I mean, I'm, I'm not like taking anything away from that.'

Why it matters: Both speakers frequently admit when they're unsure about facts or need to verify information

Citing Evidence

Referencing specific sources and documents

Examples:

Dave Smith mentions 'the yet means yet memo' from the head of the CIA
References to Gallup polls about Ukrainian support for the war
Citing specific documents from Tulsi Gabbard's release about Russiagate

Why it matters: They support arguments with specific references to documents, polls, and official statements

⚠️ Logical Fallacies

3 findings

Ad Hominem

Attacking the person rather than their argument

Examples:

Dave Smith (1m 5s): 'An expert, emotion expert, emotional support comedian.'
References to Doug having 'a degree in English' as dismissive of expertise

Why it matters: Dismissing opponents based on their credentials rather than addressing their arguments

Hasty Generalization

Making broad conclusions from limited examples

Example:

Dave Smith (47m 55s): 'It's just the way it is. When, when the value of assets is going up and up and up and up, that's great. If you own stuff, that's great.'

Why it matters: Making sweeping statements about economic systems based on limited analysis

False Dichotomy

Presenting only two options when more exist

Example:

Dave Smith (2h 3m 28s): 'So that's where your debate is at this point. Where are we between genocide and war crimes?'

Why it matters: Presenting the situation as only having two possible interpretations

🧠 Cultish / Manipulative Language

3 findings

Us vs. Them

Creating division between groups

Examples:

References to 'the establishment' vs 'the people'
Dave Smith (1h 51m 14s): 'the relationship between the US government and the Israeli government is so freaking bizarre'

Why it matters: Creates a binary division between corrupt elites and regular people